Solar ROI vs the Stock Market: Which Is the Better Investment?
Solar panels deliver an IRR of 8–12% in good states — competitive with the S&P 500's long-run ~10%. Here is the honest solar vs stock market comparison for 2026.
By The PVFig Editorial Team · 2026-08-10 · reviewed against EIA, NREL and DSIRE sources
The IRR comparison
In high-rate or strong-incentive states, a cash-purchased solar system delivers a 25-year IRR of roughly 8–12% (including rate escalation) — comparable to the S&P 500's long-run ~10%. In cheap-power states, solar IRR drops to 3–5%.
Why solar is different from stocks
Solar is a bond-like, inflation-hedged asset: your "dividend" is a locked-in electricity price for 25+ years as utility rates rise. It is illiquid (hard to sell part of a system) and location-specific, but it is also low-correlation with markets and tax-efficient in states with credits.
When solar beats the market
If you are in a 7–9 year payback state, plan to stay 15+ years, and would otherwise hold cash — solar beats the market on a risk-adjusted basis. If you are in a 15-year payback state or plan to move, stocks win. Run the ROI calculator for your exact IRR.
FAQ
Is solar a better investment than the stock market?
In good states, solar IRR (8–12%) rivals the S&P 500's long-run average — with lower correlation and inflation hedging. In weak states, stocks win.
What is the typical IRR of a solar system?
8–12% in high-rate/strong-incentive states; 3–5% in cheap-power states (cash purchase, 25-year horizon).
Is solar a good investment in 2026?
Yes in ~7–9 year payback states (HI, MA, NY, NJ, MD), especially if you plan to stay 15+ years. Check your state's payback before deciding.
Ready to compare real installer quotes?
The estimates above are based on public data — your actual price depends on your roof, installer, and market. EnergySage collects quotes from pre-screened installers in one place (free, no obligation).
Compare quotes on EnergySage →
We may earn a commission if you sign up through links above — it never affects our data or estimates.
Sources
- U.S. EIA — electricity rates by state, eia.gov/electricity/monthly
- NREL PVWatts v8 — solar production by location, pvwatts.nrel.gov
- DSIRE — state incentives and net metering, dsireusa.org
- See how every figure on this page is calculated — PVFig methodology.
Comments powered by GitHub Discussions — enable by configuring the Giscus repo in
app/components/Comments.tsx.